Beyond ‘Eat Less, Move More’: The Myth of Inactivity

by | Feb 22, 2024 | Exercise, Lifestyle, Treatments

Medical Review by Chris Palmer, MD

In a groundbreaking study published in Nature Metabolism, researchers led by John R. Speakman et al. have unveiled a critical, yet previously overlooked, factor in the obesity epidemic—a significant decline in basal energy expenditure (BEE) over the past three decades. This finding not only challenges the prevalent narrative that reduced physical activity is a driver of obesity but also opens new avenues for understanding and addressing this complex health issue. This article delves into the study’s findings and explores their implications for the Brain Energy theory, which posits a fundamental link between metabolic health and mental well-being.

The Study’s Key Findings

The study analyzed data from the International Atomic Energy Agency Doubly Labelled Water database, focusing on energy expenditure measurements from adults in the United States and Europe. The analysis included total energy expenditure (TEE), basal energy expenditure (BEE), and physical activity energy expenditure (AEE) from a substantial cohort of 4,799 participants. Contrary to the common belief that decreased physical activity over the years has led to increased obesity rates, the study found that:

  • Adjusted TEE, accounting for body composition and age, has declined since the late 1980s.
  • Adjusted AEE has actually increased over time, indicating that reduced physical activity is not the culprit behind rising obesity rates.
  • A significant decrease in adjusted BEE was observed, particularly in males, with a broader dataset of 9,912 adults across 163 studies corroborating this decline in both sexes.

These findings suggest that the increasing prevalence of obesity in the United States and Europe is likely not fueled by reduced physical activity but rather by a decline in basal metabolic rates.

Implications for the Brain Energy Theory

The Brain Energy theory, which highlights the crucial role of metabolism in mental health, gains further support from these findings. Basal energy expenditure represents the energy used by the body at rest to maintain vital functions such as breathing, circulation, and cellular metabolism—processes that are fundamental not only to physical health but also to brain function. The decline in BEE suggests a broader shift in metabolic health that could have far-reaching implications for mental well-being.

Metabolism and Mental Health

The connection between metabolic health and mental health is increasingly recognized as a pivotal aspect of both preventing and treating mental disorders. Metabolic processes provide the energy necessary for brain function, supporting everything from neural activity to neurotransmitter synthesis. A decline in basal metabolic health could, therefore, impact brain energy levels, potentially contributing to the development or exacerbation of mental health issues such as anxiety, depression, and cognitive decline.

Reevaluating Treatment Approaches

This new understanding of the obesity epidemic’s underlying factors calls for a reevaluation of treatment approaches. Traditional interventions have heavily focused on increasing physical activity and managing dietary intake. While these remain important, the findings suggest that strategies aimed at enhancing metabolic health and, by extension, basal energy expenditure, could also play a critical role. This could include approaches targeting metabolic regulation, such as dietary adjustments to improve insulin sensitivity or interventions to enhance mitochondrial function.

Future Research Directions

Further research is needed to fully understand the mechanisms behind the decline in BEE and its implications for both physical and mental health. Studies exploring the interaction between basal metabolic rates, brain energy levels, and mental health outcomes could provide valuable insights. Additionally, investigating potential interventions to counteract the decline in BEE and enhance metabolic health could offer new pathways for preventing and treating obesity and related mental health issues.

The study by Speakman et al. represents a significant shift in our understanding of the obesity epidemic, highlighting the importance of basal metabolic health as a key factor. This insight not only challenges existing narratives around obesity and physical activity but also reinforces the critical link between metabolism and brain function encapsulated in the Brain Energy theory. By focusing on enhancing metabolic health, we may open new doors for improving both physical and mental well-being, offering hope for more effective obesity treatments and mental health interventions in the future.

PTSD and Mitochondria

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a complex mental health condition that can develop after exposure to a traumatic event. This disorder is characterized by symptoms such as flashbacks, severe anxiety, and uncontrollable thoughts about the event. Recent research...

Cat Ownership and Schizophrenia: A New Perspective

A new study published in the Schizophrenia Bulletin found an intriguing connection between cat ownership and the risk of developing schizophrenia-related disorders and psychotic-like experiences. This systematic review and meta-analysis offers a new understanding of a...

Contraceptives and Mental Health

In recent years, our understanding of the intricate relationship between hormones and mental health has deepened significantly. From the rollercoaster of emotions during menstruation to the emotional challenges faced during pregnancy and menopause, it's clear that...